Tricked and Treated

There was some great treat today. Chelsea, Ana, Emily, Katelyn and Rachel were all dressed up in the Halloween costumes. They were all too good and it is very difficult to rate. Here is my rating for costume:

1. Chelsea
2. Ana
3. Katelyn
4. Rachel

5. Emily

My rating for the girls is:
1. Katelyn
2. Rachel
3. Chelsea
4. Ana
5. Emily

Do you concur?